EC/United States agreement: application of positive comity principles in the enforcement of their competition laws
1997/0178(CNS)
Parliament should give its approval to the agreement between the EU and the
United States on the application of "positive comity" principles in the
enforcement of the competition laws of the two sides. This was the position
taken by the Committee, when it unanimously adopted a report by Franco
MALERBA (UFE, I).The agreement follows on from the 1991 EU-US Agreement on
the application of the competition laws of the two parties. Article V of the
1991 agreement introduced the concept of "positive comity", meaning that if
a Party believes that anticompetitive activities carried out on the
territory of the other Party are adversely affecting its interests, the
first party may notify the other and may request their competition
authorities take appropriate enforcement measures.
The rapporteur of the External Relations Committee shares the Commission's
view that the new agreement is an important step forward from the 1991
agreement, as it not only provides guidelines on how positive comity
requests should be dealt with, it also introduces a presumption that in
certain circumstances a Party will defer or suspend its own enforcement
measures. The main point at issue is, in fact, extraterritorial application
of competition rules, which has been a recurrent bone of contention in EU-US
relations (as illustrated by the case of the Helms-Burton Act).
The new agreement emphasises the option of substituting international
cooperation for extraterritorial application of competition rules where
appropriate. In particular, a presumption of deferral or suspension of
enforcement measures by a Party would "normally" apply where:
-the anticompetitive activities in question did not have a direct,
substantial and reasonably foreseeable impact on consumers in the Requesting
Party's territory, or
-the anticompetitive activities did have such an impact on the Requesting
Party's consumers but occurred principally in and were directed principally
towards the other Party's territory.
This provision therefore adequately covers the case of extraterritorial
application based solely on the effect on the export markets of the
Requesting Party (as envisaged under US law) and introduces a presumption
that such measures will be suspended.