Humane trapping standards: Agreement between EC and the United States on international standards of trapping
1997/0360(CNS)
OBJECTIVE: to conclude an international agreement between the Community and the USA on
humane trapping standards equivalent to that concluded in 1997 between the Community, Russia
and Canada.
SUBSTANCE: Under Regulation (EEC) No 3254/91, the Community prohibits the introduction into
the Community of pelts and manufactured goods of certain wild animal species originating in third
countries unless the country in question has prohibited the use of leghold traps or uses methods that
meet internationally agreed humane trapping standards.
In June 1996, the Council authorized the Commission to negotiate a framework agreement on
humane trapping standards with Canada, the United States and Russia. An agreement was reached
in July 1997 only between the Community, Canada and Russia (see 'fiche de procédure' CNS97019).
The aim of the new proposal is to conclude a similar agreement with the USA, with which no
agreement has so far been concluded.
As a result of the negotiations, an agreement was initialled on 03.12.1997 which, like the agreement
with Canada and Russia:
- provides for the adoption of harmonized humane trapping standards relating to traps for killing or
catching certain wild mammals (particularly the species referred to in Regulation (EEC) No
3254/91),
- lays down that communications and cooperation between the parties are to be improved in order
to apply and develop these standards,
- provides for trade between the parties to be facilitated.
The agreement, concluded in the form of an agreed minute or understanding, in particular lays down
a common framework with a view to the use of less cruel traps and trapping methods, which the
respective competent authorities are responsible for applying (in the case of the United States, both
national and tribal authorities).
More specifically, the agreement provides for:
1) thresholds and indicators by means of which to measure the degree of 'welfare' of animals to be
killed or captured,
2) adoption of a timetable for compliance by traps with the standards laid down in the agreement:
.3 to 5 years after the entry into force of the agreement for restraining traps,
.5 years for killing traps,
3) a ban on all traps not certified as complying within 3 years of the deadlines laid down in the
timetable for compliance (however, derogations are provided for whereby certain traps which do not
comply may temporarily be used, particularly with the aim of taking account of certain cultural or
environmental aspects).
In a letter annexed to the agreement, the United States states that the use of all leghold traps to catch
ermine or muskrats will be banned 4 years after the entry into force of the agreement between the
EC, Canada and Russia on humane trapping (these two species account for about 50% of all animals
trapped in the United States). For all other species, the use of conventional metal leghold traps will
be banned 6 years after the entry into force of that agreement.�