Displaced persons: temporary protection
1997/0081(CNS)
The Commission has presented an amended proposal for joint action concerning temporary protection
of displaced persons to take account of discussions and exchanges of views in the Council on this
question and Parliament's opinion of 23 October 1997. Firstly, in the light of discussions in the
Council, it seems appropriate to divide the proposal into two sections to enable the Council to
continue its work and to move forward from a major point which is currently blocking the proposal,
the principle of solidarity of joint action involving sharing the burden (including the financial burden)
of temporary refugees between Member States. The controversial matter of sharing the burden of the
temporary protection mechanism has been separated from this revised version and is contained in a
new proposal (CNS98222) with the two sections of the same text normally coming into force
simultaneously. Among the major amendments to the initial text (apart from division of the text with
regard to the financial provisions) are:
- more precise definitions of the field of application: the temporary protection regime will apply
'in the event of a mass flight of persons' and will not prejudice possible recognition of refugee
status in future,
- some subsidiarity elements (the Member States are free to take national measures as long as
the Council has decided to apply joint action; they also have to decide whether to authorise
beneficiaries to remain on their territory or to grant them a temporary work permit),
- more details on review and phasing out of the temporary protection scheme,
- some derogations (in particular with regard to authorisation to remain on the territory of a
Member State: this may be refused on grounds of public security and public order),
- the link with refugee status (another controversial point in the proposal): if a beneficiary
under the scheme applies for asylum, the application must be examined in accordance with
the national law and pursuant to the Dublin Convention on determination of the Member
State responsible for an asylum applications; Member States are authorised to suspend
examination of an asylum application for five years; if asylum is not granted on completion
of the procedure, the applicant is nevertheless still covered by the temporary protection
scheme as long as the situation is in line with that described in the joint action; an asylum
seeker may not combine the advantages of the two systems (they are either refugees or
beneficiaries of temporary protection);
- limitation of benefit: financial support is to be granted to beneficiaries under this scheme
where they have no income.
The Commission has also incorporated, either in letter or in spirit, ten of the 22 amendments adopted
by Parliament:
- geographical region and place of origin of displaced persons: this must correspond to the area
adjacent to the geographical region from which the displaced persons come;
- reference to the European Convention of Human Rights;
- duration of temporary protection: five years at most;
- content of reports presented by the Commission (these must include the social implications
of temporary protection in the Member States);
- specific measures with regard to unaccompanied minors;
- information to be submitted to Parliament.
�