Institutional and legal implications of the use of 'soft law' instruments
The Committee on Legal Affairs unanimously adopted a report drawn up by Manuel MEDINA ORTEGA (PES, Spain) on the institutional and legal implications of the use of 'soft law' instruments. It considered that, in the context of the Community, soft law often constituted an ambiguous and ineffective instrument which was liable to have a detrimental effect on Community legislation and institutional balance. It should be used with caution, even where it was provided for in the Treaty. The Committee further considered the open method of coordination to be legally dubious, as it operated without sufficient parliamentary participation and judicial review. It should be employed only in exceptional cases and Parliament should become involved in the procedure.
The Committee deplored the use of soft law by the Commission where it was a surrogate for EU legislation that was still necessary per se, or where it extrapolated the case-law of the Court of Justice into uncharted territory. The institutions were urged to refrain from adopting soft-law instruments when draft legislative acts are under consideration. The Commission should give special consideration to the effect of soft law on consumers and their possible means of redress before proposing any measure involving soft-law instruments.
As regards Commission communications, green and white papers did not give rise to any direct legal obligations. However, the adoption of consultation papers and political declarations of intent should not be seen as implying any legal obligation to enact the corresponding regulations. Whilst the Commission interpretative communications serve the legitimate purpose of providing legal certainty, their role should not extend beyond that point. When they serve to impose new obligations, interpretative communications constitute an inadmissible extension of law-making by soft law. When a communication laid down detailed arrangements not directly provided for by the freedoms established under the Treaty, it was departing from its proper purpose and was thus null and void. Communications satisfying the criteria referred to above should consequently be issued only in those cases where Parliament and the Council, in other words the legislature, had instructed the Commission to draw up the necessary interpretative communications. The Committee considered that translating the Treaty into reality was the responsibility of the legislature and that its interpretation was the responsibility of the Court of Justice.
Standardisation and codes of conduct were important elements of self-regulation. However, standardisation must not lead to overregulation and constitute an additional burden for small and medium-sized enterprises in particular. The legal bases concerned should incorporate built-in safeguards against overregulation.
Parliament, as the only democratically elected Community institution, was not currently consulted about the use of so-called soft-law instruments, such as Commission recommendations, based on Article 211 of the EC Treaty, and interpretative communications. The Committee called on the Commission to develop a modus operandi that guaranteed the participation of the democratically elected bodies including, possibly, by means of an interinstitutional agreement, and thus more effective monitoring of the need for the adoption of 'soft-law' instruments. Such an agreement should, in particular, aim to resolve the contradiction that has arisen as a result of the rules in Articles 211, 249(5) and 230 of the EC Treaty and in the case-law of the European Court of Justice, when the Court requires the national courts to take due account in current legal disputes of recommendations which are per se non-binding under the Treaty.